How to Plant Heirloom Tomatoes

This post may contain affiliate links, which means I may earn a small commission if you make a purchase through these links — at no extra cost to you. Thank you for supporting the content I create here on the blog! You can read my full Disclosure Policy for more details.

If you’ve ever bitten into a store-bought tomato and thought, “Well, that was… disappointing,” then it’s time you learned how to plant heirloom tomatoes. These colorful, juicy, and flavor-packed beauties put bland supermarket varieties to shame. They’re not just tomatoes—they’re living pieces of history passed down through generations.

Whether you’re dreaming of slicing into a meaty Brandywine for your next BLT or showcasing rainbow-colored slicers on a summer salad, growing heirlooms at home is easier (and more rewarding) than you think. In this guide, you’ll learn how to plant heirloom tomatoes from seed to harvest—no green thumb required.

From choosing the right variety to prepping your soil, protecting your plants from pests, and even saving seeds for next season, we’ll cover everything you need to know. So grab your gardening gloves—it’s time to dive into how to plant heirloom tomatoes like a pro.

What Are Heirloom Tomatoes?

Before we dig into the dirt on how to plant heirloom tomatoes, let’s clear up what makes them so special.

Heirloom tomatoes are varieties that have been passed down for generations—often 50 years or more—grown and preserved for their exceptional flavor, unique colors, and historical roots. Unlike supermarket hybrids bred for uniformity and shelf life, heirlooms are all about flavor, character, and diversity.

You’ll find heirloom tomatoes in shades of deep purple, bright yellow, striped green, and even pink. Names like Cherokee Purple, Mortgage Lifter, and Green Zebra aren’t just fun—they tell a story. These tomatoes were lovingly saved by home gardeners, farmers, and seed savers who valued taste over appearance.

Another big difference? Heirloom seeds are open-pollinated, meaning if you save the seeds from your best tomato this year, you can grow the same variety again next season. That’s a huge bonus once you learn how to plant heirloom tomatoes and fall in love with your favorites.

In short: heirlooms = tomatoes with personality.

Choosing the Right Heirloom Tomato Variety

Now that you know what makes these tomatoes so special, the next step in learning how to plant heirloom tomatoes is picking the right variety for your garden—and your taste buds.

There are hundreds of heirloom tomato types out there, and each one has its own personality. Some are rich and smoky, others sweet and tangy. Some are compact and great for containers, while others grow like wild jungle vines that need serious support.

Things to Consider When Choosing a Variety:

• Climate Compatibility
  If you live in a shorter growing season, go for early producers like Stupice or Glacier. Hotter climates? Arkansas Traveler and Cherokee Purple love the heat.
• Growth Habit: Determinate vs. Indeterminate
  Determinate (bush-type) tomatoes grow to a certain size and stop—perfect for small spaces and container gardens. Indeterminate varieties keep growing and producing all season long, but they’ll need staking and pruning. If you’re serious about how to plant heirloom tomatoes for a long harvest, indeterminate is often the way to go.
• Flavor and Use
  Want slicers for sandwiches? Try Brandywine. Making sauce? Go with San Marzano or Amish Paste. Just want to snack right off the vine? Cherry types like Black Cherry are ridiculously good.
• Disease Resistance
  While heirlooms aren’t as disease-resistant as hybrids, some varieties are tougher than others. Look for those that are known to stand up to common issues like blight and wilt—especially if you’re just learning how to plant heirloom tomatoes and want a smooth first season.
• Where to Buy Seeds or Starts
  Trusted seed companies like Baker Creek, Seed Savers Exchange, or Johnny’s Selected Seeds offer a wide range of heirlooms. You can also check local nurseries or seed swaps.

Once you’ve chosen your tomato soulmate(s), you’re ready for the next big step in how to plant heirloom tomatoes—preparing your garden and getting those babies in the ground.

Preparing to Plant Heirloom Tomatoes

You’ve picked your perfect varieties—nice work! Now it’s time to get prepped. A successful garden starts before the seeds ever hit the soil. If you’re serious about mastering how to plant heirloom tomatoes, this step is crucial.

Whether you’re starting from seed or buying young plants, the key is creating the right environment from the beginning.

Starting from Seed (Indoors)

Want total control and more variety? Start your heirloom tomatoes from seed indoors 6–8 weeks before your last expected frost.

Here’s what you’ll need:

• Seed trays or small containers with drainage
• A sterile seed-starting mix (light and fluffy, not garden soil)
• Full-spectrum LED grow lights (a sunny windowsill usually isn’t enough)
• A heat mat (optional, but tomatoes germinate faster with bottom heat)

Pro Tip: Label everything! Many heirlooms look alike when small, and you will forget what’s what.

Buying Transplants

New to gardening? No shame in skipping seed starting. You can find heirloom seedlings at farmers markets, plant sales, and some garden centers. Look for:

• Healthy green leaves (no yellowing or spots)
• Strong stems
• No visible pests or mold

Hardening Off Your Plants

Before planting outdoors, you’ll need to harden off your seedlings—aka gradually introduce them to sunlight and outdoor temps over 7–10 days. This prevents shock and sad, wilty plants.

Start with an hour or two in a shady spot, then slowly increase their time and sun exposure each day.

Once they’ve toughened up, you’re ready for the real deal: digging in and actually planting your heirloom tomatoes in the ground.

Soil Preparation and Garden Setup

If you want to grow big, beautiful tomatoes, your soil has to be on point. One of the secrets to mastering how to plant heirloom tomatoes is knowing that tomatoes are hungry plants—they need rich, well-draining soil packed with nutrients.

So let’s get your garden beds or containers ready for heirloom greatness.

What Kind of Soil Do Heirloom Tomatoes Love?

• Loamy and well-draining – Too much clay = soggy roots. Too sandy = dried out. Aim for that “just right” Goldilocks mix.
• Rich in organic matter – Mix in compost, aged manure, or worm castings.
• Slightly acidic – Ideal pH is 6.0–6.8. You can buy a simple soil test kit here.

If you want to take your tomato growing to the next level, a raised garden bed can improve soil drainage and quality significantly. These beds are easy to maintain and give your plants a nutrient-rich home.

Pro Tip: If you’re planting in raised beds or containers, use high-quality potting mix and amend with compost. Don’t use soil straight from your yard—it’s often too compacted and may harbor diseases.

How to Prep the Bed (or Container)

1. Clear the area – Remove weeds, grass, and debris.
2. Loosen the soil – Dig down at least 12 inches to break up compacted soil.
3. Add amendments – Mix in compost, organic tomato fertilizer, and a handful of crushed eggshells (for calcium).
4. Set up supports now – Trust us, trying to stake a full-grown tomato plant is a nightmare. Use cages, stakes, or trellises at planting time.

Growing in Containers?

Totally doable—and great for small spaces. Just make sure:

• Your container is at least 5 gallons in size.
• It has drainage holes.
• You water more frequently (containers dry out faster).

Once your soil is prepped and your supports are in place, you’re officially ready for the star moment in how to plant heirloom tomatoes—getting those seedlings into the ground.

How to Plant Heirloom Tomatoes (Step-by-Step)

Alright, dirt’s prepped, tomatoes are toughened up, and you’ve got your garden game face on. Now we get into the fun part: how to plant heirloom tomatoes the right way so they thrive from day one.

Here’s your foolproof, step-by-step planting process:

Step 1: Choose the Right Time

Don’t rush it! Tomatoes are warm-weather lovers. Wait until after your last frost date, when nighttime temps are consistently above 50°F (10°C). Cold soil = stunted plants.

Step 2: Dig Deep

This is one of the coolest tricks when learning how to plant heirloom tomatoes: plant them deep.

• Strip off the bottom few leaves of your seedling.
• Dig a hole so deep that two-thirds of the stem is buried.

Why? Tomato stems grow roots when buried, giving your plant a massive, stronger root system.

BONUS TIP: Add a tablespoon of crushed eggshells or bone meal in the hole for calcium—this helps prevent blossom end rot.

Step 3: Water as You Plant

Give your tomato plant a good soak as you plant it. Moisture at the root zone helps reduce transplant shock and gets things off to a healthy start.

Step 4: Support Early

Add your cage, stake, or trellis now while the plant is small—don’t wait until it’s a jungle. Your heirloom tomatoes will need help as they grow tall and heavy with fruit.

Step 5: Mulch It Up

Once planted, add 2–3 inches of organic mulch (like straw, shredded leaves, or compost) around the base. This keeps the soil moist, suppresses weeds, and protects your plants from disease splash-back.

Step 6: Choose a Sunny Spot

Heirloom tomatoes need at least 6–8 hours of direct sun a day. The more, the better—sunlight = sweet, flavorful fruit.

Caring for Heirloom Tomatoes

Now it’s time to shift into maintenance mode. This is where many gardeners make or break their tomato season. Learning how to plant heirloom tomatoes is only half the battle; caring for them properly is what turns good plants into great producers.

Let’s walk through what your heirlooms need to thrive:

Watering: Consistency Is Key

Tomatoes are thirsty, but they hate soggy roots. The trick? Deep, consistent watering.

• Water at the base, not overhead (this helps prevent fungal diseases).
• Aim for 1–2 inches per week, depending on heat and rainfall.
• Water early in the morning so leaves can dry quickly.

To keep your heirlooms perfectly watered without the daily hassle, consider an automated drip irrigation system with timers and moisture sensors. These systems deliver water directly to the roots and help prevent overwatering or drought stress.

Pro Tip: Stick your finger into the soil. If the top inch is dry, it’s time to water.

Mulching: Your Secret Weapon

Already mulched? Awesome. If not, now’s the time. Mulch helps with:

• Retaining moisture
• Reducing weeds
• Keeping soil temps steady
• Preventing soil-borne diseases from splashing up

Use straw, shredded leaves, or even grass clippings (dried)

Fertilizing: Feed for Fruit, Not Just Leaves

Too much nitrogen = big leafy plants and no tomatoes. Balance is everything.

Pruning: Optional, but Powerful

Pruning helps boost airflow, prevent disease, and focus energy on fruit production.

• Remove suckers (those little shoots in the “V” between the main stem and a branch).
• For indeterminate types, consider pruning lower leaves once the plant is established.

Don’t overdo it—just tidy things up.

Support as They Grow

If you’re growing indeterminate heirlooms, they’ll keep growing and growing. Tie the vines gently to your stakes or trellis as needed. Use garden tape, soft twine, or even old T-shirts (seriously!).

Learning how to plant heirloom tomatoes is about more than just putting them in the ground—it’s about creating the right conditions week after week. Keep up with watering, feeding, and a little TLC, and you’ll be rewarded with juicy, flavorful fruit you’ll never find in a grocery store.

Common Pests and Diseases (and How to Handle Them)

Even if you’ve nailed every step in how to plant heirloom tomatoes, your plants can still face enemies in the garden. Heirlooms are known for their flavor, not their disease resistance—so keeping an eye out for trouble is key to a successful harvest.

Here’s what to watch for—and what to do about it:

Common Pests

1. Tomato Hornworms

These giant green caterpillars can strip a plant overnight.

• Signs: Chewed leaves, droppings, and the worm itself.
• Solution: Hand-pick and toss ’em. For large infestations, use Bt (Bacillus thuringiensis), an organic pest control.

2. Aphids

Tiny green or black bugs that cluster on stems and leaves.

• Signs: Sticky residue (honeydew), curled leaves.
• Solution: Spray with insecticidal soap or introduce beneficial insects like ladybugs.

3. Whiteflies

Small, fluttery bugs that hide under leaves and suck plant sap.

• Signs: Yellowing leaves, clouds of white when disturbed.
• Solution: Yellow sticky traps or neem oil.

Common Diseases

1. Early Blight & Late Blight

Fungal diseases that cause brown spots and wilting leaves.

• Prevention: Space plants well for airflow, mulch to prevent soil splash, avoid overhead watering.
• Treatment: Remove affected leaves, use a copper-based fungicide if needed.

2. Septoria Leaf Spot

Tiny dark spots with yellow halos—starts low and moves up.

• Solution: Same as blight—remove damaged leaves, keep plants dry, and rotate crops each year.

3. Blossom End Rot

Black, sunken spots on the bottom of the fruit—caused by calcium imbalance.

• Solution: Water consistently, add calcium (crushed eggshells or garden lime), and avoid over-fertilizing with nitrogen.

Pro Tips for Pest & Disease Prevention

• Rotate crops every season—don’t plant tomatoes in the same spot two years in a row.
• Clean up dead leaves and fruit to stop disease spread.
• Don’t crowd your plants—airflow is your best defense.
• Inspect weekly—early detection = easy solutions.

Staying vigilant is part of mastering how to plant heirloom tomatoes successfully. With a little awareness and a quick response, you can keep most problems in check before they impact your harvest.

Harvesting and Saving Seeds

After all that planting, watering, staking, and fussing, it’s time to reap the rewards. Knowing how to plant heirloom tomatoes is just the beginning—harvesting them at peak ripeness and saving seeds for next year takes your garden game to the next level.

When to Harvest Heirloom Tomatoes

Heirloom tomatoes don’t always turn bright red—some ripen to purple, yellow, green-striped, or even pink hues. So how do you know when they’re ready?

Look for these signs:

• Color has fully developed for the specific variety.
• Fruit feels slightly soft when gently squeezed (not rock-hard).
• Tomatoes easily twist off the vine with little effort.
• Aroma is rich and sweet near the stem.

Pro Tip: Don’t refrigerate heirloom tomatoes! It dulls their flavor. Leave them on the counter and eat within a few days.

How to Save Heirloom Tomato Seeds

One of the coolest perks of heirlooms? You can save seeds from your best plants and grow them again year after year. Here’s how:

Step 1: Choose a Perfect Tomato

Pick a ripe, healthy tomato from a strong, disease-free plant. Avoid saving seeds from the first fruits—choose mid- or late-season tomatoes for better genetics.

Step 2: Scoop and Ferment

• Cut the tomato open and scoop the seeds (with the gooey gel).
• Put them in a jar with a little water and cover loosely.
• Let it sit for 2–4 days, stirring once daily. A white mold layer will form—this is normal and helps remove the germination-inhibiting gel.

Step 3: Rinse and Dry

• Once fermentation is done, add more water, stir, and let the good seeds sink to the bottom.
• Pour off the top layer (floating seeds = duds).
• Repeat until only clean, heavy seeds remain.
• Dry them on a paper towel or coffee filter for about a week, then store in a labeled envelope or jar.

Bonus: Saved seeds can last 4–6 years if stored in a cool, dry place.

FAQs About How to Plant Heirloom Tomatoes

If you love this post...

25 Slow Living Summer Bucket List Ideas for the Dreamiest Summer Ever

10 Indoor Plant Styling Ideas That’ll Instantly Elevate Your Home

How to Create a Slow Living Kitchen

How to Cook Beets: 5 Easy Methods for Perfect Flavor

Death by Chocolate Zucchini Bread

How to Fall Asleep Fast with Insomnia

The Best Peach Cobbler Recipe with Frozen Peaches

How to Make Pickles Without Vinegar