How to Make Butter in a Jar

This post may contain affiliate links, which means I may earn a small commission if you make a purchase through these links — at no extra cost to you. Thank you for supporting the content I create here on the blog! You can read my full Disclosure Policy for more details.

There’s something incredibly satisfying about making a staple food from scratch—especially when it turns out to be way easier than you expected. Case in point: homemade butter. Yes, real, creamy, spread-on-everything butter… made right in a jar. No special tools, no fancy ingredients, and no churning device straight out of an old farmhouse required.

If you’ve ever wondered how to make butter in a jar, you’re in for a treat. This simple DIY butter method uses just one main ingredient and about 10 minutes of shaking (consider it your arm workout for the day). It’s perfect for beginners, kids’ activities, cozy weekends at home, or anytime you want to feel a little more homemaker chic without actually committing to homesteading.

Whether you’re looking for an easy kitchen project, a fun experiment to try with kids, or a way to make your toast feel extra special, this jar butter recipe is proof that sometimes the simplest things really are the best. Let’s get shaking

What You Need to Make Butter in a Jar

One of the most charming things about making homemade butter in a jar is how unfussy it is. No stand mixer. No churn. No specialty tools hiding in the back of your kitchen cabinets. This is a back-to-basics recipe in the best way.

Essential ingredients and tools:

• Heavy whipping cream
  This is non-negotiable—only heavy cream has enough fat to turn into butter. Look for cream with at least 36% milk fat. The fresher the cream, the better your butter will taste and smell. If you use grass-fed or organic cream, you’ll often notice a deeper yellow color and richer flavor.
• A glass jar with a tight-fitting lid
  A mason jar works perfectly, but any clean jar that seals securely will do. The key is leaving space—fill the jar only halfway so the cream can whip and then break properly.
• Salt (optional)
  Fine sea salt dissolves best and brings out the natural sweetness of the butter. Start conservatively; homemade butter tends to need less salt than store-bought.
• Optional flavor additions
  Honey, herbs, roasted garlic, cinnamon, or even citrus zest if you’re feeling creative.

This method is ideal if you’re learning how to make butter at home for the first time because it strips the process down to its simplest form.

How to Make Butter in a Jar (Step-by-Step)

Step 1: Measure and Add the Cream

Pour heavy whipping cream into your jar until it’s about halfway full. Resist the urge to add more—this extra space is essential. It allows the cream to whip into soft peaks first before the fat solids separate into butter.

Seal the jar tightly. If you’d like, give it a quick test shake over the sink just to be safe.

Step 2: Shake the Jar Until the Butter Separates

Begin shaking the jar in steady, rhythmic motions. In the first few minutes, the cream will sound thin and splashy. As air incorporates, it thickens into whipped cream, and the sound becomes duller and quieter.

This phase can feel endless—but keep going.

Eventually, the texture shifts dramatically. You’ll suddenly feel a solid lump forming inside the jar, and the sound changes again as liquid starts splashing around that solid mass. That moment is the fat fully separating from the liquid, officially creating butter.

This process usually takes 10–15 minutes, depending on:

• The temperature of your cream
• How vigorously you’re shaking
• The fat content of the cream

If your arms get tired, this is the perfect excuse to take a break or pass the jar along. Historically, butter-making was a communal task—and it still works beautifully that way.

Step 3: Pour Off the Buttermilk

Once the butter has clearly separated, open the jar and strain off the liquid into a bowl or measuring cup. This liquid is fresh buttermilk, and it’s completely usable.

It’s thinner than store-bought buttermilk, yet perfect for:

• Pancakes or waffles
• Biscuits
• Quick breads
• Marinades

What remains in the jar is soft, fresh butter—pale, slightly glossy, and incredibly satisfying to look at.

Step 4: Rinse the Butter Carefully

Rinsing the butter isn’t optional if you want it to last. Leftover buttermilk trapped in the butter can cause it to spoil more quickly.

Add cold water to the jar, gently swirl the butter, then pour out the cloudy liquid. Repeat this process several times until the water runs completely clear.

Use a spoon or spatula to gently press the butter against the side of the jar, releasing any hidden liquid pockets. Take your time here—this step greatly improves both texture and shelf life.

How to Flavor Your Homemade Butter

Homemade butter is a blank canvas, and flavoring it turns a simple spread into something genuinely special. Once rinsed, the butter is soft enough to mix easily without melting.

Flavor ideas that work especially well:

• Salted butter: Add salt in small increments, mixing well and tasting as you go
• Honey butter: Blend in honey until lightly sweet and smooth—perfect for toast or muffins
• Garlic butter: Use finely minced or roasted garlic for mellow flavor
• Herb butter: Soft herbs like parsley or chives, or woody herbs like rosemary (very finely chopped)

After flavoring, you can shape the butter into a log using parchment paper or press it into a small jar for easy storage and serving.

How to Store Homemade Butter

Because this butter is fresh and preservative-free, proper storage matters.

• Refrigerated: Store in an airtight container for up to 1–2 weeks
• Frozen: Butter freezes exceptionally well and can be stored for several months

If freezing, divide it into small portions so you can thaw only what you need. Labeling the container with the date is always a good idea, especially if you plan to make butter regularly.

Tips for Making Truly Great Butter

• Shake continuously rather than starting and stopping
• Warm cream churns faster, cold cream stores longer
• Don’t skip the rinse—it improves flavor and longevity
• Use fine salt so it distributes evenly
• Trust the process; separation can feel sudden, but it will happen

Making butter in a jar is one of those simple kitchen skills that feels timeless. It’s practical, a little magical, and surprisingly empowering—proof that some of the best kitchen wins are also the simplest.

FAQs About Making Butter in a Jar

How long does it take to make butter in a jar?

Making butter in a jar usually takes 10 to 15 minutes of shaking, depending on how warm the cream is and how vigorously you shake. Warmer cream churns faster, while colder cream may take a few extra minutes but often produces butter that stores better.

Can you make butter in a jar with milk?

No—regular milk won’t work. To make butter in a jar, you need heavy whipping cream with a high fat content. Butter forms when fat separates from liquid, and milk simply doesn’t contain enough fat to make that happen.

Why isn’t my butter forming?

If your butter isn’t forming, it usually just needs more time. Keep shaking. Sometimes the whipped cream stage can linger longer than expected before suddenly breaking into butter. Overfilling the jar or using low-fat cream can also slow the process.

Do you have to rinse homemade butter?

Yes, rinsing homemade butter is important. Rinsing removes leftover buttermilk, which helps the butter last longer and prevents it from developing a sour taste. Continue rinsing until the water runs clear for best results.

Is homemade butter healthier than store-bought butter?

Homemade butter contains one simple ingredient—cream—with no preservatives or additives. While it’s nutritionally similar to high-quality store-bought butter, many people prefer it for its freshness and clean ingredient list.

How do you store butter made in a jar?

Store homemade butter in an airtight container in the refrigerator for up to two weeks. For longer storage, butter can be frozen for several months without losing flavor or texture.

What is the liquid left after making butter?

The liquid left behind is buttermilk. It’s thinner than commercial buttermilk but works well in baking recipes like pancakes, biscuits, and quick breads. It can be stored in the fridge for a few days.

Can kids help make butter in a jar?

Yes! Making butter in a jar is a fun, hands-on kitchen activity for kids. With adult supervision to ensure the lid stays sealed, it’s a safe and engaging way to learn where food comes from.

Loved this post?

ABOUT THE AUTHOR

Lisa, Slow Living Enthusiast

Hi, I’m Lisa. I write about slow living, nervous system care, and creating calm, intentional routines for everyday life. After spending 10 years living in Europe, I learned firsthand the art of savoring moments, embracing simplicity, and letting life unfold at a more human pace. My mission is to help you soften the edges of modern life and create space for a more intentional way of living.